THE CALL OF SHECHEM: LIBERATION DEMANDS DECISIONS
A Journey Through Black History, Faith and Our Wall Against Erasure
PART III — WE HAVE BEEN HERE BEFORE
Part II ended with a proposition that deserves care:
Black people have been here before.
That does not mean history repeats itself exactly. It does not. We are not living in 1877. We are not living under the legal architecture of Jim Crow. The institutions are different. The laws are different. Black Americans possess constitutional rights, political representation, educational opportunities, economic resources, and institutional power that generations before us fought to make possible. But history does not have to repeat itself to instruct us. Sometimes history reveals a pattern.
First, challenge the legitimacy of Black advancement. Then weaken or dismantle the structures that made that advancement possible. Finally, alter the story of why those structures existed in the first place, until what was won through struggle begins to look unnecessary, excessive, or undeserved. Reconstruction provides one of the clearest examples.
FREEDOM HAD TO BE DEFINED
The Civil War ended slavery, but emancipation alone could not determine what freedom would mean. That question had to be fought out.
Would formerly enslaved people simply cease to be property, or would they become citizens with enforceable rights? Would they vote? Hold office? Own property? Receive an education? Serve on juries? Participate in the institutions governing the nation whose wealth their labor had helped create?
The 13th Amendment abolished slavery except as punishment for crime. The 14th Amendment established birthright citizenship and equal protection under the law. The 15th Amendment prohibited denying the right to vote on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.
These were not minor adjustments to American law. They represented a profound restructuring of the legal relationship between Black people and the United States.
And Black Americans did not wait passively for freedom to be defined for them.
They organized political conventions, established schools and churches, reunited families torn apart by slavery, acquired land where they could, built businesses and institutions, voted, served on juries and entered government. Black men were elected to local offices, state legislatures, Congress and the United States Senate.
Hiram Revels and Blanche K. Bruce represented Mississippi in the Senate. Robert Smalls, who had liberated himself and others from slavery by taking control of a Confederate transport ship, later represented South Carolina in Congress.
This was more than Black advancement. It was Black citizenship being exercised. And almost immediately, the legitimacy of that citizenship was challenged.
FIRST, DELEGITIMIZE THE PROGRESS
Black political participation during Reconstruction was portrayed by its opponents as evidence of corruption, incompetence, and social disorder. Black officeholders were depicted as unprepared for citizenship. The expansion of democracy itself was recast as an illegitimate imposition upon the South.
That narrative did not remain rhetorical.
White supremacist organizations used murder, intimidation, economic retaliation, and terror to suppress Black voting and destroy Black political participation. The Ku Klux Klan was only the most notorious among organizations that understood something very clearly:
Political rights written on paper mean little if people can be terrorized out of exercising them.
Federal intervention suppressed some of that violence for a time, but federal commitment weakened. Reconstruction ended. White political control was reestablished across the South. Then came the architecture of disfranchisement.
Poll taxes, literacy tests, grandfather clauses, white primaries, racial gerrymandering, intimidation, and violence stripped Black citizens of political power. Segregation hardened throughout public life. In 1896, Plessy v. Ferguson supplied constitutional protection for “separate but equal,” giving legal sanction to a racial order in which separation was enforced, and equality was largely fiction.
A generation had witnessed Black people move from enslavement into citizenship and political participation. Another would inherit a society constructed to make that transformation appear to have failed. And then something else happened. The history was rewritten.
THEN ERASE WHY IT HAPPENED
For generations, one of the dominant accounts of Reconstruction portrayed it as a disastrous experiment imposed upon a defeated South: corrupt governments, incompetent Black officeholders, and vindictive federal intervention.
The former Confederacy was rehabilitated through the mythology of the Lost Cause. Confederate leaders became defenders of regional honor. The centrality of slavery to secession was obscured. Slavery itself could be softened into a paternal institution. Black political participation became evidence of Reconstruction’s failure rather than evidence of an extraordinary expansion of American democracy.
This interpretation did not remain inside academic arguments. It entered classrooms. It entered textbooks. It entered monuments and commemorations. It entered films and popular culture. It entered American memory. And once embedded there, it helped explain and justify the racial order that followed.
That is the power of erasure.
If you erase the conditions that made a remedy necessary, the remedy itself can be made to look unjust. If you erase the struggle required to obtain a right, that right can begin to look like an undeserved privilege. If you erase the violence used to remove political power, the people who lost that power can be blamed for having failed to keep it.
First, delegitimize the progress. Then dismantle it. Then rewrite the history that explains why it existed.
That sequence should command our attention now. Not because 2026 is Reconstruction. Not because every contemporary policy disagreement is Jim Crow by another name.
And not because every effort to reform a government program constitutes racial erasure. It should command our attention because history teaches us what can happen when a society separates its present arrangements from the conditions that produced them. A remedy without its history can be made to look like favoritism. A protection without its history can be made to look unnecessary. An achievement without its history can be made to look inevitable. And a people separated from the history of their own struggle may have difficulty recognizing what is being lost until much of it is already gone.
OUR WALL AGAINST ERASURE
But erasure was never complete. That matters enormously. Black people preserved another record.
Black historians challenged the official narratives. W. E. B. Du Bois’s Black Reconstruction in America confronted the prevailing interpretation of Reconstruction and insisted upon the agency of formerly enslaved people in building American democracy. Carter G. Woodson built institutions devoted to researching, preserving and teaching Black history because he understood that control over historical knowledge affected how Black people understood themselves and how the nation understood them.
But scholars alone never built our wall against erasure.
Black newspapers remembered. Historically Black colleges and universities remembered. Teachers remembered. Families remembered. Organizers remembered. And the Black church remembered. Names were spoken. Stories were repeated. Testimonies were given. Spirituals carried meanings that could survive where written records did not. Funerals became acts of remembrance. Sunday schools taught lessons larger than the printed curriculum. Mass meetings joined scripture to strategy. Elders told children what had happened before those children were old enough to understand why they needed to know it.
This was not nostalgia. It was transmission. One generation was telling another: This happened. This is how we survived it. This is what it cost. This is what we learned. Do not forget. That is our wall against erasure.
It is not made of stone. It is made of memory, institutions, scholarship, faith, testimony, family, culture, journalism, organizing and the deliberate transmission of truth from one generation to another. And walls require maintenance.
MEMORY MADE THE NEXT STRUGGLE POSSIBLE
The twentieth-century Black freedom struggle did not emerge from a people without memory. It emerged from communities that remembered what had been taken.
People knew that Black men had voted during Reconstruction. They knew Black people had held political office. They knew schools and institutions had been built. They knew segregation had not descended upon the South as some natural social arrangement. It had been constructed. And what had been constructed could be challenged.
Brown v. Board of Education confronted legalized school segregation. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 attacked discrimination in employment and public accommodations. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 placed federal power behind protection of the ballot. Fair housing protections followed. Federal equal employment requirements expanded. Affirmative action developed from recognition of a stubborn reality: prohibiting future discrimination did not automatically repair the accumulated consequences of past discrimination.
These measures were not gifts bestowed upon Black Americans by a suddenly enlightened nation. They were governmental responses to years of organizing, litigation, protest, political pressure, sacrifice and, too often, blood. People marched because they remembered. They organized because they understood. They persisted because they knew the condition confronting them had been created by human decisions and therefore could be changed by human decisions.

THE GENERATION THAT “MISSED ALL THE HARD STUFF”
One phrase from Rev. Dr. Lee H. Sapp’s sermon has stayed with me. Joshua was speaking to a generation, she reminded us, that had “missed all the hard stuff.”
They inherited what another generation had struggled to reach. That observation reaches far beyond the sanctuary. Many Black Americans alive today were born after the Civil Rights Act. Many were born after the Voting Rights Act. They never encountered a poll tax. They did not have to consult a Green Book before traveling. They did not walk past a WHITE ONLY sign to find the entrance assigned to them. They did not watch a parent turned away from a voting registrar’s office. Thank God they did not. That was the purpose of the struggle. Our ancestors did not endure those things so their descendants could experience them more authentically. They struggled so that their descendants would not have to experience them at all.
But success creates its own historical danger. When the barrier disappears, eventually people may forget why the protection was built. When the exclusion is no longer visible, the remedy may begin to look excessive. When the struggle passes beyond living memory, the achievement can begin to look as though it had always been there. I posit that this is why Joshua recited the history.
As Dr. Sapp said, “He didn’t call them there merely to remember history. He called them there to make a choice about their future.”
The remembering prepared them for the choosing. And that may be the most important connection between Shechem and the moment before us. The purpose of preserving Black history is not to remain permanently turned toward yesterday. We remember because history equips us to recognize what stands before us today. Memory informs understanding. Understanding sharpens discernment.
Discernment reveals the choice.
That is why attacks upon historical memory matter beyond museums, monuments, websites, and textbooks. When memory is weakened, our capacity to recognize patterns can be weakened with it. Our wall against erasure protects more than the past.
It protects our ability to discern the present.
And once we have discerned what is before us, Shechem asks the question history cannot answer for us.
What will we decide?

